There are three ratings for each (new) review:
Overall Quality is an judgement on story, characters, animation and music
Overall Enjoyment is a judgement based purely on enjoyment factor
Recommendation is how much I recommend it, with Full Moon being the highest and New Moon being the lowest.
Symbols/Numbers
A
Aku no Hana | Amnesia: The Animation | Angel Beats! | Another | Ao No Exorcist
B
C
D
Daily Lives of High School Boys | Dangan Ronpa: The Animation | Deadman Wonderland | Death Note | Deltora Quest | Durarara!!
E
ef - a tale of memories | Elfen Lied
F
FLCL | Free! Iwatobi Swim Club | Fullmetal Alchemist | Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
H
Hell Girl | Hellsing Ultimate | Hetalia: Axis Powers
K
Kekkai Sensen | Kuroshitsuji I
L
M
N
Naruto | Now and Then, Here and There
O
P
Persona 4 | Ping Pong The Animation | Psycho-Pass
S
Soul Eater | Space Dandy |Steins;Gate | Sword Art Online
T
U
X