I can't help but think that Vash would totally be more popular if had dozens of video games and a time slot that wasn't on at 1 in the morning.
I love seeing how Vash grows during the series, putting away his forced smile and learning to make difficult decisions, like with his fight with Legato and Knives. In comparison, Goku takes that kind of moral dilemma in stride, either blasting away foes with blinding kamehameha waves and never seeing the last look on their faces, or showing mercy to crippled foes like Captain Ginyu and Frieza only to be screwed over in the preview of the next episode of DragonBall Z.
Last edited by KeenHavoc at 9:23:25 AM CDT on May 18, 2011.
Well I finished three episodes of Trigun. Vash kind of reminds of a mix between Spike Speigel, Keroro and Son Goku. Though it looks like a fairly even matchup. Seems like each candidate is get his due.
Last edited by Hisaishi at 7:27:57 PM CDT on May 17, 2011.
I voted Vash, cause when I was younger my lil bro and I used to stay up all night to watch Trigun. His bonde broom hair, silver gun, red coat, and bright blue eyes will always have a high place in my heart. Besides his character is in my opinion more rounded than Goku's......but dang did they really have to pair these two up. I def would have voted Goku over some of these other characters. Based on DBZ's impact on anime. But Vash is just.....epic ^^
DBZ was my starting point in anime when i was 9, so i vote Goku.. but they are a pretty close match up.. dbz was my favorite untill One Piece came along =)
Vash obviously, I mean, look at the list of things to consider, Vash wins all hands down except the last one , especially in back story and emotional complexity.
I feel that Vash might lose just because shonen jump fans like the dragonball series a little too much to make a thoughtful choice and consider both as viable candidates.
It's hard to choose! I used to love Trigun back in the day and Vash is a little more intriguing than Goku. Goku, however, has had the fate of the world in his hands a few more times than Vash. Goku gets my vote! :D
darnit! how the heck do they even make these match-ups anyways??...Voted Vash, even though he hasn't got a chance, I still stand by ya, you blond broomhead! :( lol
Goku and the entire dragonball series has way too much rabid fandom behind it built up over such a long time. I just don't see the contest here. *facepalm*
Admittedly, Vash has a bit more depth to him than Goku in a few areas, but for me, the sticking point here is "How they've influenced the anime world". Goku without a doubt.
@Katana: Nope I'm saying Vash over Goku too, so you aren't alone there.
Goku has contributed a lot to anime over the years, but I find Vash to be a more compelling and layered character than Goku, who seems to be a pretty run of the mill Shounen character. I will admit that I am slightly biased, since I never really cared for DBZ and have always preferred Trigun. But I really do just think that Vash is a better character overall.
I was at first thinking Goku - I mean, he's classic. But then I re-read the list of what to consider and I have to admit, Vash really comes off as a guy with more depth and character than Goku does.
Gonna be the first (and probably only) person to say "Vash" in the comment box.
Goku for sure, I mean, Goku isn't just an iconic anime character, he was also inspired by the Monkey King from Journey to the West making Goku represent much more than just Dragonball.
Madman With a Box (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
See, this is actually tough. This is a true match-up, because both characters are equally awesome, and very similar in terms of personality.
Although I do love Trigun, in the end I had to go with Goku. If we're talking "greatest anime character", Dragon Ball is a legend, and the personification of that legend is Goku
shinigami117
Otakuite++ | Posted 06/15/11 | Reply
I think they're both too goody-goody but I prefer Goku.
cougarsama
LDS Fangirl! (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/20/11 | Reply
Definitely Vash; he's a sweetheart and actually mortal.
Angel
Chat Guardian (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/18/11 | Reply
its a tough choice both r good animes but one is better and tht is vash from trigun
KeenHavoc
Grand Otaku | Posted 05/18/11 | Reply
I can't help but think that Vash would totally be more popular if had dozens of video games and a time slot that wasn't on at 1 in the morning.
I love seeing how Vash grows during the series, putting away his forced smile and learning to make difficult decisions, like with his fight with Legato and Knives. In comparison, Goku takes that kind of moral dilemma in stride, either blasting away foes with blinding kamehameha waves and never seeing the last look on their faces, or showing mercy to crippled foes like Captain Ginyu and Frieza only to be screwed over in the preview of the next episode of DragonBall Z.
Last edited by KeenHavoc at 9:23:25 AM CDT on May 18, 2011.
star petals
Otaku Eternal | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
This was a tough one, as both characters have strong points! Can't wait to see the results!
Hisaishi
News Correspondent (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Well I finished three episodes of Trigun. Vash kind of reminds of a mix between Spike Speigel, Keroro and Son Goku. Though it looks like a fairly even matchup. Seems like each candidate is get his due.
Last edited by Hisaishi at 7:27:57 PM CDT on May 17, 2011.
dfdfdfdf
Otaku Eternal | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
goku :D
JanetChan
Otaku Legend | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Goku
SunfallE
Nyaa~ (ZE MEANIE) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Vash and his goofy grin. <3
In the name of the tune I will punish you!
hackerblackrose
Otaku Eternal | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Vash wins for me sorry Goku you are cool and all but Vash has more character depth and he is so hot. :)
LightFykki
Drachen Herz (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Goku of course! One of the greatest anime legends to live~! :D
Hisaishi
News Correspondent (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
On the grounds that I have yet to see an episode of Trigun, I humbly retract my vote and refuse to participate in this match of voting.
On the bright side, I have decided to watch Trigun to see its quality and how it may have influenced anime as a whole.
wolf of sorrow
JMusicGuru (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Vash is epic, but let's face it, Goku is anime history. EVERYONE knows Goku unlike Vash.
wingedshadowwolf
Otaku Eternal | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Goku is cool, but Vash is epic!
I voted Vash!
Eiri Yuki s Lover
YukiFangirlSupreme (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
I voted Vash, cause when I was younger my lil bro and I used to stay up all night to watch Trigun. His bonde broom hair, silver gun, red coat, and bright blue eyes will always have a high place in my heart. Besides his character is in my opinion more rounded than Goku's......but dang did they really have to pair these two up. I def would have voted Goku over some of these other characters. Based on DBZ's impact on anime. But Vash is just.....epic ^^
Romanos Vixen
Grand Otaku | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
I'm gunna go with Vash, because he is just pure epicness, and he and his anime in general is hilarious! ^^
SRV
Guru's Chosen | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
I voted for Goku BECAUSE well....first time...long ago...little kid...anime...childhood....yeah,all of that stuff.
Shinmaru
Baron of Terribad (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Vash because Goku's Japanese voice makes me want to hang myself.
Love thy Evangelion.
SakuraDust
Moderator | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
Goku!
aminesick
D (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/17/11 | Reply
DBZ was my starting point in anime when i was 9, so i vote Goku.. but they are a pretty close match up.. dbz was my favorite untill One Piece came along =)
cannon21
Otakuite+ | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Vash obviously, I mean, look at the list of things to consider, Vash wins all hands down except the last one , especially in back story and emotional complexity.
I feel that Vash might lose just because shonen jump fans like the dragonball series a little too much to make a thoughtful choice and consider both as viable candidates.
RayMan87
Ser Pounce a Lot (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
I will go for vash coz this is not a vote to see who will win in a fight.
And well vash live like hundred and hundred years, saving anyone in any way he can. and besides he got awesome hair. <-- that counts a lot
ANyway he is just my fav anime character evah!!
I may not be smart enough to do anything, but I am dumb enough to try anything. ;p
jeweloflife
Afrofantastic (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
GOKU GOKU GOKU
HE DIED LIEK MILLION TIMES TO SAVE US!
D:<
Alchemic Mushroom
Angel (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
It's hard to choose! I used to love Trigun back in the day and Vash is a little more intriguing than Goku. Goku, however, has had the fate of the world in his hands a few more times than Vash. Goku gets my vote! :D
MaCheriexx
Grand Otaku | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
I know I shouldn't let this bother me, but it looks like a lot of people are voting based on the series rather than the character.
SG Creations
Otaku Legend | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
darnit! how the heck do they even make these match-ups anyways??...Voted Vash, even though he hasn't got a chance, I still stand by ya, you blond broomhead! :( lol
Goku and the entire dragonball series has way too much rabid fandom behind it built up over such a long time. I just don't see the contest here. *facepalm*
Ducky
Imaginary Duck (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
@Katana:
Agree. Vash all the way.
KisukeUrahara
Senior Otaku | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Admittedly, Vash has a bit more depth to him than Goku in a few areas, but for me, the sticking point here is "How they've influenced the anime world". Goku without a doubt.
Team Plasma N
Sinbad of Sindria (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
@TimeChaser:
Agree this one is a toughy compared to the previous vote.
I love both anime's but in the end DBZ is what lured me into anime so my vote is for Goku.
SolemnSerpent
Cupcake Constable (Moderator) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Goku saved the entire planet, explored and trained in the afterlife, was brought back to life multiple times, and has amazing hair.
HE WINS.
But on a fashion note, Vash pwns all.
LilyGinnyBlack
Otakuite+ | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
@Katana: Nope I'm saying Vash over Goku too, so you aren't alone there.
Goku has contributed a lot to anime over the years, but I find Vash to be a more compelling and layered character than Goku, who seems to be a pretty run of the mill Shounen character. I will admit that I am slightly biased, since I never really cared for DBZ and have always preferred Trigun. But I really do just think that Vash is a better character overall.
Katana
Goggalor (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
I was at first thinking Goku - I mean, he's classic. But then I re-read the list of what to consider and I have to admit, Vash really comes off as a guy with more depth and character than Goku does.
Gonna be the first (and probably only) person to say "Vash" in the comment box.
"In Kat's wor we trust."
AshWilliams
Otakuite+ | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Goku for sure, I mean, Goku isn't just an iconic anime character, he was also inspired by the Monkey King from Journey to the West making Goku represent much more than just Dragonball.
Bluemoon Halo
Otakuite++ | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Goku!,Goku!,Goku XD!
TimeChaser
Madman With a Box (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
See, this is actually tough. This is a true match-up, because both characters are equally awesome, and very similar in terms of personality.
Although I do love Trigun, in the end I had to go with Goku. If we're talking "greatest anime character", Dragon Ball is a legend, and the personification of that legend is Goku
Bazinga!
ReiKiba
Otaku Legend | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
Obviously, Goku deserves more!
BloodyKiss14
Otakuite+ | Posted 05/16/11 | Reply
I love you vash but goku owns me so I'm sooo sorry but yea. He's had such an impact on the anime community it's not even funny.