Ah, didn't know that. But then I wouldn't really bother anyway, I have plenty yet unwatched that I'd rather focus the Currently Watching list on anyway.

@TimeChaser:

If you click the Edit link for an anime on your list there'll be a little check box next to the status selection for flagging it as rewatching and then a text box to enter what episode you're on. If you enable that the series will be moved back up to the Currently Watching section of your list with the little rewatching flag next to the title and the episode count will be whatever you set it to.

That part of it works fine, it just screws up the history entries.

Yeah, I could never quite figure out why that happens. That is the most frustrating thing about MAL -- I like it a lot, but there are all these little imperfections that bug you a bit when they all pile up together.

It might also have to do with them moving servers recently, who knows. I don't bother with things I'm rewatching, because for one thing the episode counter on the Panel and Profile always stays at 26/26 or whatever, it doesn't actually show how far you are in your rewatching. I realize that's a little quibble, but I'd prefer if they changed that too.