• AnimeArchAngel's Avatar

    AnimeArchAngel

    Tveiter Tot (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 08/11/11 | Reply

    @Katana:

    Dude I was totally thinking the same thing, and now I'm singing that Justin Timberlake song that he did on SNL. xD;

    Ahem. Anyway, yeah, I'd totally love to participate when I can! I like a lot of the things that have been said, especially comparing the different adaptations of Sherlock Holmes. Nehs mentioned DC/Marvel vs anime, which made me think of Marvel vs DC. I guess with that though not a whole lot of people pay attention to it (not that that's a bad thing, and not that I know everything ever about it either, since I've never even actually read the comics. Instead I just sit here hogging all the Iron Man stuff). What I thought of when reading this post was-- and I'm not actually sure if it's unpopular, but I think it is-- is slash and how none of us like it. Perhaps we could do a special talking about that? Or would that be getting into, like, bad territory? Something else might be Durarara vs Baccano, which is pretty random but I guess because they're kind of similar it might work? I'm just spouting off things that come to mind. We could talk about the different types of anime (like for example, I like the moe moe stuff but you don't, so we could talk about that, or just compare all the different genres in general).

    Anyway, that's all I can think of for now, but I'll edit this if I can think of any others. Thanks for putting this out there. :)


    Last edited by AnimeArchAngel at 8:55:32 AM CDT on August 11, 2011.

  • Katana's Avatar

    Katana

    Goggalor (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 08/08/11 | Reply

    @Nehszriah:

    Haha. You said three-way.


    "In Kat's wor we trust."

  • Nehszriah's Avatar

    Nehszriah

    Hits Self With Axe (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 08/08/11 | Reply

    Here's the list I have in my binder:

    • black and white vs color
    • stuffing vs potatoes
    • Gryffindor vs Slytherin
    • MLP:FIM vs KILL IT WIF FIYAH
    • HTTYD vs TS3 (?)
    • Doctor A vs Doctor B (or we could do a three-way and do 9, 10 and 11)
    • Disney film vs Disney film (or Pixar vs Pixar)
    • manga vs anime (the mediums)
    • DC/Marvel vs manga
    • western cartoons vs Japanese anime
    • fangirlism vs fangirlism (I could be the butt of a "BUT THEY'RE DEAD" running gag when referencing some of the dudes I like staring at)
    • Hetalia vs Scandinavia and the World (I adore both, but I'll vouch for the latter.)
    • Pixar vs Dreamworks
    • book of the movie vs movie of the book
    • POM POKO! :D vs omgwtfhellno (long story)
    • Indiana Jones 4 yes! vs Indiana Jones 4 no!
    • When all else fails, there's always sports banter.

    I also had an idea that we could even do solo opinion pieces, in case there's something that one person has a stance in that the others don't really care about. Some of the topics I could bring to that table would be the Chicago (Sports) Mob (that'd take some careful wording), Avatar, Graceling (it's a hilariously awful book), The Inheritance Cycle (a hilariously awful book series) and why the Harry Potter series drops some serious balls despite all the awesome rolled up in it.

    So, yeah. We can dissect the list all we want and use what's useful. There are some of these things on the list as to where I can take either side, depending on my approach.

    EDIT: I've got some more possible topics/ideas, which I am sharing here to help the overall creative process. I'm writing everyone's down elsewhere as well so we can have a master list.

    • Harry Dresden vs Harry Potter
    • originals vs remakes (The Thing From Another World and The Thing come to mind in particular)
    • Pixar's Cars: does it really suck or not deserve the hate
    • favorite Pokemon/party strategy
    • Joel vs Mike
    • comparing different Sherlock Holmes adaptations
    • James Bond incarnations
    • comic book movies
    • Speed Racer: anime or movie (or not at all)
    • shounen vs shoujo

    Last edited by Nehszriah at 12:34:21 AM CDT on August 9, 2011.


    Be true, be you and of course, be otaku.

  • Miss Anonymous's Avatar

    Miss Anonymous

    Vagrant AI (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 08/08/11 | Reply

    I'd be willing to join in on this, provided of course that I'm familiar with the topic (herpaderp).

    Any Doctor Who topics would not work for me, as I've only seen a few episodes here and there (although Ducky could probably get in on those, if she wanted to). Basically, if the topics broach any of my nerdities, which I'll list off I guess, then I'm in.

    Here's a couple examples of what I mean:

    Tales of~ (Either Abyss, Symphonia, or Vesperia)
    .hack anything
    Disney and Pixar

    And... yeah. I don't really have a lot of ideas, minus a Disney discussion. I think that could be interesting.


    Last edited by Miss Anonymous at 10:37:11 PM CDT on August 8, 2011.

  • Katana's Avatar

    Katana

    Goggalor (Otaku Eternal) | Posted 08/08/11 | Reply

    Yeah, the balance issue was also another thing, and I totally acknowledge what you're saying. That's why I factored in sort of "specials"; if we have an overwhelming opinion we could just talk about that. I figured the sides could be even, plus or minus one person in case we have odd numbers, that sort of deal.

    I also intend for this not to become a blood bath, like, at the end of each episode we'd do a virtual handshaking or soemthing. xD


    "In Kat's wor we trust."